Why Congress won, BJP lost? - Instablogs
Why Congress won, BJP lost?
Abhishek Pandey , Delhi: May 19 2009
Made Popular May 19 2009
India :

By Abhishek Pandey
Why Congress won, BJP lost?
Speculations are over with the counting of votes. People of India have given the clear mandate for the stable government at the center by saying no to hung parliament. Indian National Congress (INC) has emerged as the largest single party. Congress has come back to power at center with the startling victory on 206 seats in the 15th Lok Sabha elections.

After people’s verdict, many political and poll analyst dropped their jaws and their eyes widened to see the caricature of the next government drawn by the electorates. Even, Congress party men and spoke person were not anticipating the victory on 206 seats by their party on its own. Congress has helped UPA to touch the tally of 262 seats and is very near to the magic number of 272 needed to form the government. This is the congress’s notable performance in last two decades since 1989.

BJP lost the elections in many states, even in its strongholds. BJP is limited to 116 seats in this General Election, which is less than its 2004 performance, 138 seats. BJP performed badly in Madhya Pradesh, Rajasthan, Delhi, Haryana, and Uttarakhand. Right wing Party has gained little in Bihar, Karnataka and Gujarat, where they wee expecting a clean sweep. Though, its ally in Bihar, Janta Dal (United), has done a very good job by winning 20 seats out of 40 seats.

Not only BJP but its allies also performed poorly in many states except JD (U). Shiromani Akali Dal (SAD) decreased from 8 to 4 seats. In Punjab, ‘weak prime minister’ tag to Manmohan Singh cost dearly to BJP and its ally SAD in Sikh dominated Punjab. Contradicting BJP’s view about a Sikh prime ministerial candidate Manmohan Singh, Indian National Congress secretary general Rahul Gandhi coined a term ‘Sher-e-Punjab’ for him which possibly swung the votes in the favour of the party in the state.

In Maharashtra, Shiv Sena and BJP alliance came down from 25 seats in 2004 to 20 seats in 2009. Metropolitan cities Mumbai and Delhi was swept by Congress party, despite BJP’s strong Internet campaigning. BJP’s campaigning on the Internet to do ‘Obama’ in India was a failure because Internet penetration in India is just 5%. BJP did not think that most netizens would not go to vote in the scorching heat of April-May.

This is the victory of Rahul Gandhi. Aam Aadmi has accepted Rahul Gandhi, Sonia Gandhi and possibly, Manmohan Singh as their leaders. BJP’s poll plank and the tag ‘weak PM’ gifted to Manmohan Singh proved to be a disaster for the party. Negative campaigning backfired BJP badly in the elections. They talked more about terrorism, failures of UPA government; black money in Swiss banks, Bofforse scam and Ram Temple instead of any development plans in the future. But nothing worked for them and party seemed to be confused on its agenda. Electorate also could not understand that what BJP would do for them after coming to power.

Youth factor of Rahul Gandhi worked for Congress in this lection. Rahul Gandhi’s canvassing in slums, villages and in tribal areas brought fruits for the grand old party. His canvassing and ability to mix up with the youths in the universities campuses and in his rallies worked well. Uttar Pradesh, which has given six prime ministers to the country, is known for caste based politics. But voters voted for congress and it shattered Mayawati’s dream to become the prime minister of the country. Dalits, who constituted approx 23% of the state population, get attracted in large numbers to the Congress. It seems that they have also fed up by seeing Mayawati’s statue and memorials on almost every cross-road and park.

Mayawati was expecting a big swell in her seat share in the state but congress maimed her party by attracting Muslims and Dalits to its court. Not going with Samajwadi party in the election helped Congress to increase its seat share from 9 in 2004 to 21 seats in 2009. Samajwadi party (SP), Rastriya Janta Dal (RJD) and Lok Janshakti Party (LJP) repented for not going with Congress in the last general elections. Congress wave across the nation crushed the ambitions of many parties.

It was the wrong notion among the political intellects that Narendra Modi can swing votes any where in the country with his unbeatable vibrant Gujarat dream for every state. Actually, Narendra Modi’s charisma did not work in any pocket of the country. In Bihar, where he did not campaign because JD (U) did not want to annoy its Muslim voters, BJP and JD (U) performed well by winning 32 seats in comparison to 11 seats in 2004 elections. Modi proved to be ineffective in cowbelt also. Varun Gandhi, a new Hindutava face of the right wing party did not do any benefit to the saffron party, not even in Uttar Pradesh.

Madhya Pradesh was also hopeless for the BJP and party’s number dwindled from 25 seats in 2004 to 16 seats in 2009. They did not get the expected gain in Karnataka and Gujarat and gained marginally by one seat and touched the tally of 19 seats and 16 seats respectively. BJP got worst news from Rajasthan and came down to 4 seats from its 21 seats’ tally in 2004. Congress swept Uttarakhand by winning all the five states, where BJP is ruling in the state.

Congress and UPA have significantly improved their performance in many states. Congress have challenged the regional parties like Samajwadi Party, Bahujan Samaj Party, Telgu Desham Party, Shiromani Akali Dal, Shiv Sena and Left parties in their strongholds. Congress with its allies has done a good job in West Bengal, Tamilnadu, Punjab, J&K and Maharashtra. Kerala and West Bengal results have threatened the red brigade. Trinmool congress (TC) won 19 seats in west Bengal. Congress restrained Left parties to a low score of 4 seats in Kerala.
Why Congress won, BJP lost?
Left parties and BJP conceded its victory and stated that they failed to convey their message to the electorates effectively. This election has brought many changes for many parties. LK Advani has been rejected as the prime minister of the country. BJP has to think about the acceptable candidate for the higher post in the party. Since, Advani is not in the mood to lead the party anymore. It is the right time for senior BJP leaders to replace him and choose someone else as the opposition leader of the party in the lower house. Left should also think about their stand on economical and development issues, which cause their defeat in their strongholds.

The election has also given a message to the next government that the people of India have shown their faith in stability by not giving fractured mandate.
It is still uncertain that did they vote for the dynasty or for development?

Add Images and Videos
Close X
Recommended Tags or Keywords
Search by Tags or Keywords
Selected Media ( You can Upload only Six media )
Sorry no picture found for this combination of tags. Try to search minimum number of tags at once
1 Stars
Yash
Bhopal, India
Abhishek
People voted for Congress because they couldn’t find any appropriate alternate to it.
1 Stars
Yes, results speak the same loud and clear.
1 Stars
Nitesh
Chennai, India
@ Abhishaek
It’s really a big question that why people again and again are accepting the dynastic rule of Gandhi- Nehru family?
1 Stars
@Nitesh

Your question is valid. Congress chairperson should give the chance to other politicians also to lead the party. Inner democracy with in the party is needed.
1 Stars
Andy
Navi Mumbai, India
We can’t say that people have voted in favor of economic policy of Congress. In fact it’s a mandate in favor of stability and against the ineffectiveness of BJP.
1 Stars
Stability and Gandhi wave made them win in the election. I am happy that we did not get hung parliament.
1 Stars
Ayushi
Calicut, India
Two factors worked really well for Congress:

1. Negative campaigning by BJP, which turned off the voters
2. Rahul Gandhi is seen as a hope for the youth and good future of nation
2 Stars
Ayushi, I am toatlly agree with your statement.. and If Congress really won the elections using money and media power even they have started a news channel Shakti It’s a news channel.
1 Stars
Ayushi, youth factor worked for the congress. And i think BJP’s budgiya-Gudiya compaign was a failure.
1 Stars
Shivangi Singh
New Delhi, India
I think making terrorism and Ram mandir election issues has costed BJP heavily.It is high time that national parties have a sensitive approach towards such issues, mudslinging is not what we want our parties to engage in.People of india want development even if along with it comes dynasty politics.
1 Stars
@Shivani
You are right. It is the need of the hour in the time of crisis.
3 Stars
It’s not a election, It’s like a product campaigning. They invest money in marketing and advertisment......
But who’s money is this?
How much they will earn?
If they are not earning any thing then why they are investing?
1 Stars
Chintan
Ambala, India
You raised a genuine issue. The elections now are not the battle of ideas. It’s just like a product campaign in which major political parties hire the PR companies to promote their symbols and make positive impression of leaders.
1 Stars
@Rachna

Recently someone disclosed that there are 138 crorepati Congress MPs ! What can we expect from these millionaires?

..Congress ka haath garib ke saath...
1 Stars
The elections to Parliament and State Legislatures are very expensive and it is a widely accepted fact that huge election expenditure is the root cause for corruption in India. A candidate has to spend lakhs of rupees to get elected and even if he gets elected, the total salary he gets during his tenure as an MP/MLA will be meagre compared to his election expenses. How can he bridge the gap between the income and expenses? - publicly through donations and secretly through corruption. Donations by Corporates and liquor barons to parties / candidates are often to get policies favourable for their business.

Corruption occurs as a chain reaction here. Representatives and party men collect bribes from people for allotting govt. or semi govt. posts and for transfers in various departments. These officials will in turn collect bribes from the public to get their things done. The situation is not beyond imagination, if police and judicial officers get their posting through back door. We don’t have to find more reasons why criminals are not just supporting elected representatives and instead becoming ‘representatives’ themselves. The very essence of democracy is defeated when money power rules and the equation becomes – of the Deprived, by the Bigwigs, for the Privileged. Criminalisation of politics can be uprooted only if this situation is avoided.

Can we reduce the election expenses for candidates?
We can achieve a significant reduction in election expenses for candidates by adopting a two-tier approach. For the parliament or state legislatures, each constituency may be divided into around 500 to 1000 sub-constituencies depending on the size of the constituency. The voters of each sub-constituency may elect a rep (primary rep / people’s rep or PR) for their sub-constituency. These PRs (who form an electoral college) shall elect from themselves (or otherwise) the rep for the constituency. Here a candidate will have to convince only the PRs what he can do for the constituency and the country. The PRs can consult their voters thereafter and elect a rep accordingly for their constituency. The duty of a PR doesn’t end with this election, instead can double as Public Relations personnel for the elected rep.

For more details,
A two-tier representation can reduce election expenses and corruption
1 Stars
Prasad
Howrah, India
Arvind

The MPs of BJP and congress is merely a conglomeration of feudal and industrialists. Where are the representatives of common men in these parties?
1 Stars
It’s not Rahul factor but money factor that worked wonder apart from positive results from states like WB,Kerala ,Tamilnadu ,Andhra and Mahrastra with the help of fruitful alliances.In nearly all these states BJP has always been in weak position.

One thing more:More than half a dozen ministers in UPA government lost the elections.

Mumbai-city hit by the worst terrorist attack-still did not find enough reasons to vote. As a result nearly 37 percent of the voters out of 74 percent educated electorates went to vote.I am presenting Maumbai as example to highlight that this time the voting percentage fell to all time low in almost all the places.So to say Indian people are comfortable with the rule of
Congress is nothing but bullshit.
Well, the election results should force the parties to reshape their priorities.If BJP learns to anticipate the moods of electorates which now more ”Daal-roti” oriented and yet retain it’s distinctiveness, it can easily gain its lost charishma.

This well know Hindi saying discloses the actual reason why Congress emerged as winner:

ALLAH MEHRBAAN TO GADHA PEHLWAAN !!
1 Stars
Correction:

Well, the election results should force the parties to reshape their priorities.If BJP learns to anticipate the moods of electorates who are now more ”Daal-roti” oriented and yet retain it’s distinctiveness, it can easily gain its lost charishma.

***********************************

You can also visit the link to know about other reasons :

http://indowaves.instablogs.com/entry/in-depth-analysis-of-verdict-2009-from-eyes-of-a-critic/
1 Stars
Brij Lal Gupta
Bulandshahr, India
Right Arvind
1 Stars
@Brijlal

The political analysts are misleading with their half-baked findings.They are viewing the victory from wrong angles.One expects a better analysis from media persons but they are simply fooling the people by highlighting stupid things that have to do nothing with the victory of Congress.

Those who are highlighting Rahul’s ”coming of age” or for that matter the analysts who are trying to project Congress as people friendly party are simply distorting the truth.

Itihas jyadatar vijetaoen ka hi itihas hota hai.Kyonki Congress jeet gayi hai hai isliye ab mediawale Congress ka gungaan kar rahe hai.Media ab sach nahi dikhata bus wohi dikhata aur batata hai jis sein uskein swarth ko kuch phayada pahuchein.Baat bas itni hai Rahul Baba ka hungaan karne ke pichein !!
Add your Comment